Your client requires Professional Indemnity or E&O insurance: what to check and what to send your broker
Contracts with foreign clients, supplier questionnaires and tender terms often include a clause on professional liability insurance: Professional Indemnity (PI) or Errors and Omissions (E&O). The first instinct is usually to find a policy with the required amount and send the certificate. But the contract requirement almost always sets more conditions than the amount, and a policy that does not meet them can cause problems exactly when the client makes a claim.
In short: copy the insurance clause from the contract and check the limit (per claim or aggregate), defence costs, territory and courts, the retroactive date, how long the policy must be kept and what certificate the client wants. With this information your broker can compare insurers' offers against the contract.
What such a requirement looks like in a contract
An illustrative example of the kind often found in English-language IT services contracts:
"The Supplier shall maintain professional indemnity insurance with a limit of not less than EUR 2,000,000 per claim and in the aggregate, covering claims brought in any jurisdiction, for the term of this Agreement and for three years after its expiry, and shall provide a certificate of insurance before commencing the Services."
This one sentence contains six requirements: the size of the limit, the type of limit (per claim and aggregate), jurisdiction, the policy term, the duty to keep the policy for three years after the contract ends and a certificate before work starts. Each is worth checking separately.
7 things to check before you sign
1. Per claim and aggregate limit
"Per claim" is the amount available for each claim; "in the aggregate" is the total for all claims in the policy period. If the contract asks for both, the policy needs both at the required level or higher. Several claims arising from one cause or a repeated mistake are usually treated as one claim with one limit.
2. Defence costs
In many PI policies, lawyers' and court costs are included in the limit. If the limit is EUR 2 million and the defence costs EUR 300,000, EUR 1.7 million is left for compensation. Some contracts require costs to be paid in addition to the limit, which has to be checked in the specific policy. The excess usually applies to each claim and may apply to defence costs as well.
3. Territory and courts
Territory is where you do the work, while jurisdiction is the countries whose courts a covered claim can be brought in. A policy with worldwide territory may still exclude claims in US and Canadian courts, and some policies also exclude enforcing a US or Canadian judgment in Europe. If the contract says "any jurisdiction" or applies US law, mention it in your request from the start.
4. Retroactive date
It sets from when your work is insured. If the retroactive date is the same as the policy start date, work done before it is not insured. If the project is already under way or you are changing insurer, check whether the new policy keeps your existing retroactive date.
5. Claims-made basis and notification
PI policies usually work on a claims-made basis: the claim must be made and notified to the insurer during the policy period. Circumstances that may lead to a claim must also be reported straight away. Claims arising from circumstances you knew about before the policy started are usually not covered.
6. How long the policy must be kept
A requirement to keep the policy for several years after the contract ends is common, because a claim over today's work may come later. In practice this means renewing the policy every year without a gap. If the policy ends and is not renewed, later claims are usually no longer covered, so if you plan to stop trading, ask about the option to report claims after the policy ends (run-off): it is not available automatically.
7. Certificate requirements
Foreign clients usually want a certificate in English. It confirms that the policy exists and shows its key details, but the cover itself is defined by the policy terms. The contract may also ask for more: the client named as certificate holder, the client added to the policy as an additional insured, a waiver of subrogation, primary and non-contributory cover or notice to the client if the policy is cancelled. Not every policy provides for this, so check it before choosing a policy, not after.
The most common mistakes
- Looking only at the amount. Two policies with the same limit can differ in the type of limit, defence costs, courts and exclusions.
- Not checking the courts. "Worldwide" in a policy does not mean claims in US or Canadian courts are covered.
- Treating PI as cyber insurance. PI covers third-party claims for professional mistakes but usually not your own costs after a cyber incident. Data loss and system unavailability are also often excluded or limited in PI policies.
- Forgetting the retroactive date when changing insurer or allowing a gap between policies.
- Signing up to unlimited liability or a broad indemnity clause on the assumption that the policy will cover it. PI usually covers liability at law, not extra obligations you take on in a contract, and usually does not cover contractual penalties or loss of profit.
- Not disclosing everything in the request. Inaccurate or incomplete information about your work, client countries or past claims can reduce a claim payment or make the policy invalid.
PI, cyber, general liability and D&O: which is which
| Policy | What it covers | What it usually does not cover |
|---|---|---|
| Professional indemnity (PI, E&O) | Third-party claims for errors, negligence or inaccurate information in your services, and defence costs | Your own losses, costs after a cyber incident, contractual penalties |
| Cyber insurance | Mainly your own costs after an incident and liability for a data breach | Professional mistakes in your services |
| General (public) liability | Injury to third parties and damage to their property | Pure financial loss from professional mistakes |
| D&O | Personal liability of board members for management decisions | The company's professional mistakes towards clients |
These policies do not replace each other. Read more about cyber risks in our article on cyber insurance for businesses, and about injury and property damage on the business liability insurance page.
What to send your broker
- the insurance clause of the contract or the supplier questionnaire questions (no need to send the whole contract);
- the date by which you need the certificate;
- a short description of your work: development, SaaS, support, integrations, consulting, outstaffing;
- your client countries (the US and Canada separately) and approximate turnover;
- your current policy or certificate and retroactive date, if you have one;
- information about past claims or circumstances that may lead to a claim.
With this information your broker can compare insurers' offers against the contract requirements and show which requirements they meet and which need clarifying with the client. Such a comparison does not replace a legal review of the contract, but it helps you avoid signing an insurance requirement you cannot meet.
How Agento helps IT companies is described on the IT professional indemnity insurance page. For consultants, agencies, accountants and other professions, see professional indemnity insurance (PCTA).
Frequently Asked Questions
What does "per claim and in the aggregate" mean?
"Per claim" is the limit for each claim; "in the aggregate" is the total limit for all claims in the policy period. If the contract asks for both, the policy needs both at the required level or higher. Also check whether defence costs are included in the limit.
Can my client be added to the policy as an additional insured?
Some policies allow it, others do not. Some policies cover a claim brought against your client because of your mistake, but that is not the same as additional insured status. If the contract asks for additional insured, a waiver of subrogation or primary and non-contributory cover, say so in your request so it can be checked before you choose a policy.
Can I sign the contract before I have the policy?
That depends on the contract wording: the certificate is often due before work starts rather than at signing. Check the deadline and agree it with the client if needed. The insurer needs time to assess the risk, so start your request early.
What if the contract requires the policy to be kept for several years after it ends?
Plan to renew the policy every year without a gap and with the same retroactive date. If you plan to stop trading, ask the insurer about the option to report claims after the policy ends (run-off), as it is not available automatically.